The protests
in Bahrain beginning in February and March 2011, centering in the Pearl Roundabout
represent some of the worst one sided violence of the Arab Spring. The
experience of Bahrain is also unique in that foreign military intervention (from
the GCC, and primarily Saudi Arabia) was used against non-violent protestors. The
crackdown was brutal, with live rounds fired on protestors, prevention of
medical treatment for protestors, arbitrary arrests, torture, imprisonment, and
in many instances death. (Although the death toll is highly disputed and there
are variances between government and activist numbers, the death toll does seem
to be above our “25 deaths per year” threshold since 2011, with at least 5
members of the security forces being killed—see bahrainrights.org for more
info).
These protests
were widely claimed by the protestors to be Bahraini in origin, not Shi’a specifically;
even though the Shi’a majority is ruled by a Sunni monarch—and much sectarian rhetoric
was used by the government in the aftermath of the protests. There were plenty
of instances of Shi’a and Sunni Bahrainis coming together. The goals of the
protests were generally for democracy, curbing corruption, and increasing job opportunities.
These seems like qualities that the U.S., the “leader of the free world” should
have been supportive of, but the U.S. was alarmingly quiet on the issue when
the protests were first taking place—of course do to other factors such as the
large navy base in Bahrain, and the proximity to Saudi Arabia and its oil. Because
of that silence, and because of the continuing protests, clashes, and repression,
we all, as students in the U.S., should care about what continues to happen in
Bahrain, especially in regards to repression of free speech.
After the
scene of the protests was razed, the government focused on taking down the
leaders of the protest movement, human rights activists, and anyone who
happened to be present. Well over 1000 protestors were arrested according to Al
Jazeera, including opposition members of Parliament, activists, poets, and even
professional footballers who had shown support. There were facebook pages
asking people to identify protestors so that justice could be delivered.
Activists have been arrested for tweeting about the protests, and the
continuing injustice—even when they encourage only non-violent tactics, such as
Zainab al-Khawaja, who was arrested only a few months ago for tweeting about
human rights violations (see New York Times article cited below).
If the
repression continues to worsen, it is likely that the protestors and government
will become more brutal and the situation will get farther out of hand and more
violent—as peaceful demonstrations were un-peacefully put down. To resolve the
issues, I would suggest a dialogue between protestors and government—although this
is horribly idealistic, unlikely to happen, and many of the protest leaders
have already been arrested. The U.S. has the obligation to at least pay lip
service to democratic aspirations of the people of Bahrain, although I feel
this opportunity has already passed. The U.S. could encourage some form of
dialogue to help end some of the gravest violations of human rights and free
speech.
As the
repression continues, and free speech and other human rights continue to be
violated, we need to keep an ever closer eye on the people of Bahrain.
Sources:
http://www.aljazeera.com/programmes/2011/08/201184144547798162.html
a great 50 minute documentary on the protests and their aftermath.
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/23/opinion/sunday/kristof-when-bahrain-said-get-lost.html?_r=0
http://bahrainrights.org/en/node/3864
I agree, the U.S. should take action and stand up for human rights in Bahrain; however, as both you and Kristof note, our country will not do this simply because of our steadfast relationship with Bahrain. According to the U.S. State Department's own website (link is listed below) Bahrain, "is a vital U.S. partner in defense initiatives." Furthermore, as you briefly mentioned, Bahrain is situated in an "oil rich" part of the world and therefore is important economically to the U.S. By standing up for the people of Bahrain (I think even by encouraging a dialogue), the U.S. will jeopardize not only only it's relationship with Bahrain, but with the rest of the Arabian peninsula.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/26414.htm
Pier, I completely agree with you. Those were too idealistic policy suggestions for the U.S. In trying to address the assignment I had to say something, and I could not, to myself, morally, suggest just letting the status quo continue.
ReplyDeleteHere is another article that sums things up pretty well. Talks are on the way, but that is likely to lead to nothing new or inspiring.
http://news.yahoo.com/talks-end-bahrain-crisis-begin-amid-mistrust-141252624.html
East Innovations offer professional web design and web development services all over Bahrain.
ReplyDeleteDigital Marketing Bahrain